Are Experimental Helicopters safe to fly?
I am often asked about the safety and reliability of the Rotorway helicopters that I fly around 400 hours a year. “Are they safe to fly?” “Safe”, does that mean that there is no risk if one flies an experimental helicopter? Does that mean that there is no risk in flying any helicopter?
A query of the NTSB accident database certainly would support that fact that accidents happen to all kinds of aircraft, both fixed and rotary wing machines. Are cars and motorcycles safe? Lets take it back further before the age of the internal combustion engine we could ask if horses are a safe way to get to point a to b. Many people are injured every year by horses.
In truth the human body is fragile and nearly anything we do has an element of risk. When I was 31 years old I had pretty much made it financially. I was in the process of installing the first wind farm in the windy hills of southern Solano County in California and president of a large wind farm company. I also owned a hot tub, spa, and solar store in Suisun California, numerous apartments and rental properties, and thought that I had it made for life. At 10pm on June 6, 1982, as I was leaving my office and driving home to my new custom home, an oncoming vehicle swerved into my path and struck my truck head-on.
I woke up on October 1 of 1984 pennyless and homeless. The head injury that I sustained in the head-on collision with the drunk teen-aged driver had caused my brain to be unable of recording memory for nearly two and a half years, during which time my business and investments evaporated. It was a long road to recovery but by the late 1980’s I was back in business and financially able to start shopping for my first Rotorway helicopter.
Since then I have accumulated over 5000 hours in helicopters, (of those hours over 4000 have been in Rotorway helicopters of varying models) and have piloted my own airplanes for over 1000 hours. During those over 6000 hours of PIC time I have never been even slightly injured, and the only “crash” that I have had was when, as a green pilot on a high density altitude day at max gross wt., I lost main rotor rpm on lift off and entered an LTE spin. I took out the tail rotor on my own ship as I set it down. That was an easy fix and within a week I was flying again.
Based solely upon my own personal experience, I could conclude that driving a vehicle on the roads exposed me to more risk than flying helicopters and airplanes. I had always thought that flying a medevac helicopter would be exciting and rewarding. In 2005 I was approached my Air Evac Lifeteam recruiters to become a medivac helicopter pilot flying the Bell 206 Longranger. I committed to fly for one year so in 2006 I divided my time between Rotorway instruction and medevac helicopter flights.
There were many times when the circumstances would put the helicopter and crew on the edge of any safety margins. I came closer to unseen wires at night while approaching or departing remote emergency scenes than I had ever flying Rotorway helicopters. I experienced wind sheer while departing from the 17th story roof top of a hospital as the 30 kt winds whipped around the elevator enclosure near the helipads. I even had a construction crane swing its boom directly into the path of the helicopter when I was on final approach to the hospital rooftop helipad. On one flight I was sprayed with a patient’s blood in-flight and it was of such a volume that it was running down the inside of the wind screen and covering my instruments and my uniform. During that year of flying medevac helicopters I was exposed to more risk than during any other period of my flying career.
Already this year there have been a number of medevac helicopter crashes, I can think of 4 off the top of my head, in which the pilots, crews, and patients were all killed. From my own experience I would have to conclude that medevac helicopter flying is the most risky flying that one can engage in.
Now let’s go back to the original question, “Is the Rotorway helicopter safe to fly?” Based upon my own experience I would have to conclude emphatically, “yes it is”. During my years of involvement with this great little helicopter I have experienced a number of failures caused by either poor design or poor workmanship.
The Rotorway helicopter has slowly evolved from a very basic one person underpowered hard to control ship to a reliable two place helicopter over its production history. There were many issues with the prior models that I have discussed in articles and on my web site http://flywithorv.com many of which have been addressed on the new Talon that Rotorway is now producing. The fuel tank outlet fittings for the Talon are now incorporating the internal washer that I designed and offered to all builders over 5 years ago. The Fatal flaw in the overhead wiring (it is simple to fix if you have this model) of the 162F has been eliminated by the total redesign of the wiring system on the Talon.
At the time of this writing there have been over 20 fatalities involving medevac helicopters flown by highly trained and highly experienced commercial pilots this year alone. As I look back at my involvement with experimental helicopters I have personal knowledge of only 3 fatalities involving these helicopters.
The first involved my good friend Bill. He died when he decided to throw water balloons out of his helicopter while flying in the traffic pattern at Mather AFB during our 1996 Western States helicopter Fly-in. When Bill told me what he was about to do I told him that he could not both fly the helicopter and throw the balloons at a ground target at the same time. He told me that he could handle it and headed for his ship with two red water balloons. The old photo below was taken as Bill was lifting off on his last flight. You can see the water balloons behind his heels on the floor of the helicopter.
Bill lifted off and as he was flying down wind he reached for the water balloons and in so doing made the wrong cyclic inputs, causing the helicopter to go “Low G” at which point his non-factory main rotor blades chopped off his tail boom.
The members of the Sierra Rotorcraft club had cautioned Bill that his NON-ROTORWAY main rotors were installed incorrectly and were unsafe. That fact combined with improper pilot control inputs put Bill in a situation that he could not survive. Bill’s crash had nothing to do with the design of his helicopter, the same thing would have and has happened many times to R22 helicopters before the factory instituted the 20 hour “Awareness Training” that every pilot must complete prior to soloing in a Robinson helicopter. Any helicopter that has a semi-ridged main rotor system is susceptible to what is know as “Mast Bumping” that can occur it the pilot makes improper control inputs. That is what proper training is all about.
Bill gave the helicopter incorrect control input and the helicopter did what it was told to do. It would be similar to driving your car down the freeway at 70mph and then jerking the steering wheel hard to the right and then back to the left. The car will do as it is directed and most likely leave the roadway with fatal results.
In short, Bill was not killed by his helicopter. He made a series of mistakes that ended up getting him killed.
The second fatal accident that I am aware of occurred when a builder was flying his experimental helicopter over a populated area after installing non-factory after market rotor blades that were designed for auto gyros. One of the main rotor blades departed the ship while in flight and the pilot was killed when the helicopter slammed into a house roof causing his death and the total destruction of the home.
The third fatal accident that I am aware of occurred around this time last summer. Jim was flying his helicopter when the improperly constructed vertical stabilizer bracket broke and the stabilizer departed the helicopter. Jim was a student pilot who had been flying for over eleven months since his phase II altitude training and solo endorsement without the required follow-up training.
When constructing the forward stabilizer bracket he placed the mounting holes in the incorrect location so he drilled new holes in the correct location in the same bracket instead of discarding the bracket. You can see both holes where the bracket broke in the photo below.
The NTSB report determined the cause of the failure to be the incorrect placement of two holes and the fact that the holes had not been de-burred after drilling them. A crack began at one of the burrs or machine marks from drilling and propagated across the bracket through the other hole.
The cracked stabilizer bracket should have been detected during the preflight or pre-boarding inspections but it was not. Eyewitnesses stated that the main rotor blades were not turning when the helicopter fell vertically from the sky. This would indicate that this student pilot had allowed his main rotor RPM to decay to the point of main rotor stall, a situation that is nearly always fatal. Had he lowered his collective immediately and entered an auto to the surface when he detected a problem occurring, he would most likely have landed safely and we would not be discussing his crash.
These are three examples of fatal accidents that were all caused by either builder error, pilot error, or a combination of the two. I have flown in hundreds of Rotorway and other models of helicopters and even if something goes wrong while in flight, there is always ample warning to the pilot to allow him/her to bring the helicopter to the surface safely to determine the cause of the unusual smell, sound, or vibration that got the pilots attention. That holds true if the helicopter is constructed correctly and flown in accordance with proper helicopter piloting techniques.
The key issues to remember here are to build the helicopter as if your life depended upon it, it does! Get the proper training so that you will pilot the helicopter correctly and will not make a fatal mistake like going “Low G” or allowing the main rotor RPM to decay to the point of “Rotor Stall”. If in doubt, auto out. If something is not right, get the helicopter to the ground and sort it out there.
So when I am asked “are Rotorway helicopters safe?” I answer that they are safe if they are built and flown correctly with proper maintenance and flight training by the pilot.
R/H Commercial, Instrument, CFI
Sho-Me Helicopters, LLC
Specializing in maintenance training and flight instruction of Rotorway Helicopters.